Health Plan Selector Calculator
Answer a few questions to find your best plan
Your Results
HMO Estimate
$0
Based on your answers and average 2025 New Zealand rates
Best for: Budget-conscious individuals with predictable healthcare needs who see their primary doctor regularly and don't need frequent specialists.
You might like: Low monthly premium, no deductible in many cases, and predictable costs for routine care.
PPO Estimate
$0
Based on your answers and average 2025 New Zealand rates
Best for: People with complex healthcare needs, frequent travel, or who value freedom of choice in providers.
You might like: No referrals needed, wider provider network, and coverage for out-of-network care.
Recommendation:
Note: These estimates are based on average rates and your specific usage. Actual costs may vary based on your location and specific provider choices.
If you’re choosing a private health plan, you’ve probably seen the terms PPO and HMO thrown around like they’re interchangeable. They’re not. PPOs and HMOs are two completely different ways to get care - and picking the wrong one can cost you money, time, or both.
What Is an HMO?
An HMO, or Health Maintenance Organization, is like a closed club. You pick one primary care doctor - your gatekeeper - and that’s who you see for everything. Need a specialist? You can’t just walk in. You need a referral from your primary doctor. No referral? The insurance won’t pay.
HMOs keep costs low by limiting you to a network of providers. If your doctor leaves the network, you’re stuck finding someone new. Out-of-network care? Usually not covered at all - unless it’s an emergency.
Think of it like a subscription service. You pay a low monthly premium, low copays, and no deductible in many cases. But you give up freedom. You can’t just go to the specialist you’ve heard good things about if they’re not in the HMO’s list.
What Is a PPO?
A PPO, or Preferred Provider Organization, gives you more control. You can see any doctor you want - in-network or out-of-network. No referrals needed. Need to see a dermatologist? Just book the appointment. No paperwork. No waiting.
But here’s the catch: you pay less when you stay in-network. Out-of-network visits cost more - higher copays, higher coinsurance, and you might have to file claims yourself. Still, the flexibility is real.
PPOs usually come with higher monthly premiums than HMOs. You might also face a deductible before the insurance starts paying. But if you travel often, see specialists regularly, or just hate being told who you can see, the extra cost is worth it.
Cost Comparison: HMO vs PPO
Money talks. Here’s how they stack up in real terms, based on average 2025 plans in New Zealand and similar private markets:
| Cost Type | HMO | PPO |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Premium | $250 | $420 |
| Deductible | $0-$500 | $1,000-$2,500 |
| Copay (primary care visit) | $15-$25 | $30-$50 |
| Copay (specialist visit) | $25-$40 | $50-$75 |
| Out-of-network coverage | None (except emergencies) | Yes, but at higher cost |
Bottom line: HMOs save you money if you’re healthy and don’t need frequent specialists. PPOs cost more upfront but give you breathing room when things get complicated.
Network Size Matters
HMO networks are tight. In Auckland, an HMO might only include 3-5 clinics in your suburb. If your preferred GP retired or switched plans, you’re out of luck. You can’t just switch doctors mid-year unless you change plans entirely.
PPOs? They’re wider. In New Zealand, major PPO networks cover over 80% of private providers - including top specialists in Wellington, Christchurch, and even rural clinics. If you’re visiting family in Queenstown and need urgent care, you’re covered. With an HMO? You’d likely pay full price.
One real example: Sarah, a teacher in Tauranga, needed a knee specialist. Her HMO only had one provider on the list - a 90-minute drive away. She switched to a PPO and found a clinic 15 minutes from home. Her out-of-pocket cost dropped from $180 per visit to $50.
Who Should Choose an HMO?
HMOs are ideal for people who:
- Don’t see doctors often
- Prefer low monthly costs
- Have a trusted GP who’s in-network
- Don’t need specialists regularly
- Like having one person manage their care
If you’re young, healthy, and just want basic coverage for colds, flu shots, and annual checkups, an HMO makes sense. It’s the budget-friendly option with no surprises - as long as you stick to the rules.
Who Should Choose a PPO?
PPOs are better if you:
- See specialists often (like physiotherapists, psychologists, or orthopedists)
- Travel frequently within New Zealand or overseas
- Want to keep your current doctor even if they’re not in a narrow network
- Have a chronic condition that needs ongoing care
- Value freedom over savings
For example, Mark, a 52-year-old with type 2 diabetes, switched from an HMO to a PPO. He saw his endocrinologist every three months, his podiatrist monthly, and his dietitian weekly. The HMO required referrals for every visit - and wait times were months long. With the PPO, he booked appointments as needed. His health improved. His out-of-pocket costs? Higher, but manageable. His peace of mind? Worth every extra dollar.
What About Out-of-Network Care?
This is where people get burned.
HMOs rarely cover out-of-network care. If you go to a specialist outside the network, you pay 100%. Even if it’s the best doctor in the country. Even if your HMO doesn’t have anyone who treats your condition. That’s not a loophole - it’s the design.
PPOs cover out-of-network care, but it’s expensive. You might pay 50% more than in-network rates. You’ll also have to submit claims manually. Some PPOs have “out-of-network deductibles” that are separate from your in-network one. Read the fine print.
One rule of thumb: If you’re not sure whether your doctor is in-network, call the insurance company. Don’t assume. Don’t Google. Call.
Referrals: The Hidden Roadblock
HMOs require referrals for specialists. Sounds simple - until you need urgent care and your GP is on vacation.
Imagine you’ve had chest pain for a week. You call your HMO doctor. They’re booked for two weeks. You wait. You call again. They say they’ll try to get you in. Meanwhile, your symptoms worsen. You finally get a referral - but the cardiologist’s earliest slot is in three weeks. That’s not care. That’s delay.
PPOs don’t require referrals. You can go straight to the cardiologist. You can get a second opinion. You can act fast. That’s not just convenience - it’s safety.
Can You Switch Between HMO and PPO?
Yes - but only during open enrollment or if you have a qualifying life event.
Qualifying events include: getting married, having a baby, losing other coverage, or moving out of your plan’s service area. Otherwise, you’re stuck until next year.
That’s why choosing the right plan the first time matters. Don’t treat it like a phone contract. Health insurance affects your daily life.
What’s the Bottom Line?
HMOs are cheaper. PPOs are freer. Neither is better - just better for different people.
If you’re healthy, predictable, and want to save money - go HMO. If you’re complex, active, or just hate bureaucracy - go PPO.
Ask yourself: Do I want to save $200 a month - or do I want to see the doctor I trust, when I need to, without asking permission?
There’s no right answer. But there’s a right choice - for you.
Can I have both an HMO and a PPO at the same time?
No, you can’t have two private health plans active at once. Insurance companies don’t allow double coverage. If you switch from an HMO to a PPO, your old plan ends. You can’t use both to get extra benefits. Some people buy supplemental insurance (like dental or optical) on top of their main plan, but not a second core health plan.
Do HMOs cover mental health services?
Yes, most HMOs cover mental health - but only if the therapist or psychologist is in-network. Many HMOs have very limited mental health provider lists. Wait times for therapy can be 6-8 weeks. PPOs usually have wider access to psychologists and psychiatrists, making them better for ongoing mental health care.
Are PPOs worth the higher cost?
It depends on your health needs. If you rarely see a doctor, probably not. But if you have a chronic condition, see specialists, or travel often, the higher premium pays for itself in time, convenience, and better outcomes. One study from 2024 found PPO users were 32% more likely to get timely specialist care than HMO users.
Can I change my primary care doctor in an HMO?
Yes, but only during open enrollment or if your current doctor leaves the network. You can’t switch mid-year just because you don’t like them. That’s why it’s critical to pick a GP you trust before signing up. Ask friends or check online reviews for doctors in your HMO’s network.
Do PPOs have higher claim rejection rates?
No. Claim rejection rates are similar between HMOs and PPOs - around 3-5%. But PPOs require more paperwork for out-of-network claims. If you forget to submit a form or miss a deadline, your claim gets denied. HMOs rarely have this issue because they handle everything internally.
Next Steps: What to Do Now
Don’t just pick the cheapest plan. Look at your last year of care:
- How many times did you see a specialist?
- Did you ever need care while away from home?
- Were you ever turned away because your doctor wasn’t in-network?
- How much did you pay out-of-pocket?
If you answered “yes” to any of those, a PPO is probably worth the extra cost. If you rarely left your GP’s office, stick with the HMO.
Call your insurance provider. Ask for a list of in-network providers. Ask what happens if you go out-of-network. Ask if referrals are required. Write down the answers. Then compare.
Your health isn’t a budget line item. Choose wisely.